Featured

receiving-code-review

Name: receiving-code-review
Rating: 5 (9202 reviews)
Author: obra

Use when receiving code review feedback, before implementing suggestions, especially if feedback seems unclear or technically questionable - requires technical rigor and verification, not performative agreement or blind implementation

TL;DR

Verify before implementing. No performative agreement. Technical correctness over comfort.

What Is It

Use when receiving code review feedback
Verify before implementing suggestions
Require technical rigor, not performative agreement
Handle unclear feedback by asking for clarification

Key Features

READ: Complete feedback without reacting
UNDERSTAND: Restate requirement in own words (or ask)
VERIFY: Check against codebase reality
EVALUATE: Technically sound for THIS codebase?
NEVER: 'You're absolutely right!' / 'Great point!'
NEVER: 'Let me implement that now' before verification

How to Use

1.READ feedback without reacting
2.UNDERSTAND by restating or asking questions
3.VERIFY against codebase reality and context
4.EVALUATE technical soundness for this codebase
5.IMPLEMENT one item at a time, test each
6.Push back with technical reasoning if wrong

Guardrails & Gotchas

NEVER: 'You're absolutely right!' (explicit CLAUDE.md violation)
NEVER: 'Great point!' / 'Excellent feedback!' (performative)
NEVER: 'Let me implement that now' (before verification)
IF unclear, STOP and ask for clarification
IF suggestion breaks functionality, push back with technical reasoning
IF can't verify, say so and ask to proceed

GitHub Stats

Author

@obra

Repository

obra/superpowers

Stars

9202

Explore More Skills

move-code-quality

@davila7

Analyzes Move language packages against the official Move Book Code Quality Checklist. Use this skill when reviewing Move code, checking Move 2024 Edition compliance, or analyzing Move packages for best practices. Activates automatically when working with .move files or Move.toml manifests.

12.4k

1.1k

1w ago

receiving-code-review

Explore More Skills

move-code-quality

e2e-testing-patterns

testing-anti-patterns